newwindowscost
The house with new fiberglass-framed windows in daylightThe house at dusk with new windows lit from inside

Vinyl vs fiberglass vs wood: window cost by frame

Aluminum and vinyl are the cheapest frames ($453 and $472 average); wood and fiberglass cost the most ($544 and $564, This Old House).

The same double-hung window with a vinyl frameThe same window with a vinyl frame at dusk
Vinyl
The same double-hung window with a wood frameThe same window with a wood frame at dusk
Wood
The same double-hung window with a fiberglass frameThe same window with a fiberglass frame at dusk
Fiberglass
The same double-hung window with an aluminum frameThe same window with an aluminum frame at dusk
Aluminum
The same double-hung window with a composite frameThe same window with a composite frame at dusk
Composite

Replacement window cost by frame material

FrameThis Old House, averageAngi, rangeHomeGuide, installed
Aluminum$453$75–400$175–1,000
Vinyl$472$100–900$200–1,500
Composite$513$300–1,200$400–2,300
Wood$544$150–1,300$800–3,800
Fiberglass$564$500–1,500$400–2,000

Prices from This Old House, Angi and HomeGuide, as they stood on November 17, 2026. The frame is a smaller share of the bill than most people expect: the five averages sit within $111 of each other.

What should the label say for my climate?

Ignore the frame brochure and read the NFRC sticker. ENERGY STAR version 7 sets the U-factor (heat that leaks out) and the SHGC (sun heat that gets in) for each climate zone. Ask for these numbers in the quote.

ENERGY STAR zoneU-factor (lower is better)SHGC
Northern≤ 0.22≥ 0.17
North-Central≤ 0.25≤ 0.40
South-Central≤ 0.28≤ 0.23
Southern≤ 0.32≤ 0.23

Specification: ENERGY STAR Residential Windows, Doors and Skylights V7, in force since October 23, 2023.

Does the window on your quote pass for your zone?

Your ENERGY STAR climate zone

Northern-zone windows can also pass through the trade-offs listed in the specification (a slightly higher U-factor with a higher SHGC); this check uses the main line only.

Direct link to the retailer; no paid deal with them today.

Is vinyl or fiberglass cheaper?

Vinyl: $472 against $564 on average at This Old House. Angi puts fiberglass at $500–$1,500 a window.

Why are vinyl windows so expensive now?

The frame is cheap; the glass package, custom sizing and the installer’s time are most of the price.

What U-factor do I need?

For an ENERGY STAR label in the Northern zone, 0.22 or lower; in the Southern zone 0.32 or lower with SHGC 0.23 or lower.